Find, save and share Public Notices that affect you in the area.
Search the Public Notice Portal What is the Public Notice Portal?What is the Public Notice Portal?
The Public Notice Portal carries statutory public notices published in local newspapers and is the fastest and most effective way of finding out what is happening in YOUR neighbourhood.
Search the Public Notice PortalA family's plan to move their home to another part of a farm has been approved despite warnings it would spread residential development into a protected Devon landscape.
South Hams District Council's Development Management Committee voted five to three in favour of a replacement dwelling at Blackdown Farm, near Loddiswell, on Wednesday, October 28, overturning a recommendation from planning officers to refuse permission.
The proposals involve demolishing an existing timber cabin and building a three-bedroom, single-storey home on the site of a dilapidated agricultural glasshouse elsewhere on the farm. The plans would not increase the number of homes on the holding.
The existing cabin, which stands close to the original farm bungalow, was granted a certificate of lawfulness for residential use in 2020. A previous application to replace it on the glasshouse site was refused in 2023.
Planning officer Charlotte Howrihane told councillors that replacing the cabin was acceptable in principle. The dispute was over moving the home more than 40 metres away from the existing residential area, into part of the farm characterised by agricultural buildings.
Officers considered that a home, with the associated lighting, cars, gardens and domestic activity, would have a greater effect on the South Devon National Landscape than the agricultural building currently occupying the site.
The council's landscape officer objected, and Ms Howrihane said the benefits claimed for the new location could be achieved by replacing or repositioning the cabin closer to its current site.
She explained that the 2023 proposal had also been refused over its size, ecology information and carbon calculations, but those issues had been addressed in the revised scheme. The latest proposed house would be 16 per cent larger than the existing cabin, compared with 56 per cent in the earlier application.
Speaking for the applicants, planning agent Amanda Burden of Luscombe Maye argued that the move would create better living conditions for a multi-generational family living on the farm.
She told councillors that the current cabin was close to the older generation's bungalow, with windows overlooked and no suitable separate garden for the younger family's two small children.
Ms Burden said: “They've got no private garden.”
Blackdown Farm near Kingsbridge (Image: Submitted)
She explained that replacing the glasshouse would allow an enclosed garden away from the parking area and would improve the privacy of both households. She said the proposed house would be approximately 24 centimetres lower than the existing glasshouse, with planting and an earth bank helping to reduce its visibility.
Cllr Lee Bonham (Loddiswell & Aveton Gifford, Liberal Democrats), who had referred the application to committee, said members needed to decide whether the improvement in residential amenity was enough to justify relocating the replacement dwelling.
He acknowledged the potential impact on the landscape but argued that additional hedging and screening could help. During the debate, he indicated that he was inclined to support the proposals.
Cllr Jacqi Hodgson (Dartington & Staverton, Green Party) raised the safety of children living around working farm machinery and said she favoured providing a separate garden.
She said: “I would want somewhere safe for little children.”
Cllr Hodgson proposed approving the scheme against the planning officer's recommendation, arguing that the low height of the building and planting could help limit the effect on the wider landscape.
Cllr Bernard Taylor (Charterlands, Conservative) said he had viewed the farm from further away and considered that the replacement home would have less visual impact than the existing structures. He seconded the motion for approval.
However, Cllr Guy Pannell (South Brent, Liberal Democrats) warned against putting one family's circumstances ahead of established planning policy, noting that future occupants might have different needs. He also questioned the effects of extending gardens and domestic activity into the agricultural part of the holding.
The council's monitoring officer, David Fairburn, reminded members that personal circumstances were generally not material planning considerations and that their decision should focus on matters such as the site's location and landscape impact.
Committee chairman Cllr Mark Long (Salcombe & Thurlestone, Independent) also opposed the scheme, saying a replacement home could be located closer to the existing residential area without creating the same separation between domestic and agricultural parts of the farm.
Members nevertheless voted five to three to approve the plans.
Conditions proposed during the meeting included demolishing the original cabin within three months of occupation of the new home, implementing the landscaping scheme, controlling external lighting, using natural timber cladding and following ecological recommendations. Officers also proposed restrictions on further extensions and outbuildings, along with a self-build condition.
The committee was told that the existing cabin was not legally tied to the farm, and the replacement home would not automatically be tied to it either. The precise wording of the planning conditions will be confirmed in the council's formal decision notice.
The application, reference 2085/26/FUL, can be viewed on South Hams District Council's planning register.
Share