Every loaf carries a little more of the landscape with it than most of us probably stop to consider. For Bertie Matthews, managing director of Matthews Cotswold Flour, the future of bread is not simply about what happens in the bakery, but what happens much earlier beneath a farmer’s feet – in the health of the soil, the water it can hold and the life it supports. As regenerative farming gathers momentum, he believes changing the way grain is grown could ultimately change something as everyday as the bag of flour in a kitchen cupboard.
The conversation comes ahead of British Regenerative Farming Week, a new annual campaign running from Saturday, September 12, to Saturday, September 19, bringing together farmers, food businesses, retailers, bakeries, manufacturers and others across the supply chain. It is a timely subject for a family milling business whose history stretches back eight generations, but which Bertie says has changed considerably during his own nearly decade-long spell there. One of the biggest shifts has been towards speciality flour, greater traceability and closer relationships with the people growing the grain.
In the factory (Image: Lewis Clarke)
“We were not in any retailer before 2020 and now we are with Tesco, Waitrose and about to launch into Sainsbury’s,” says Bertie. “We have gone from sort of a hundred thousand small bags a year to three million, so that is really, really positive. And I think the long-term strategy is a big change for us. Rather than just buying from a merchant, where grain comes from anywhere, we have implemented that 100% traceability to farm and, in many cases, to field.”
That connection between field and finished loaf is central to his argument. A baker – whether working professionally or at home – ultimately wants the flour to perform in much the same way every time, regardless of what the weather has done or which farm produced the wheat. “What they want is consistency,” says Bertie. “They want a really good tasting, great smelling loaf of bread that looks, feels and tastes the same every time. That is the quality commitment that we need to be able to give as a flour miller to bakers and to people who love bread and baked goods.”
Achieving that consistency means understanding the grain before it ever reaches the mill. “You need to be selecting your grain, your varieties of grain, in a very careful and considerate way,” he adds. “And the best way to do that is to know where it is coming from, how it has been farmed, and that has a direct impact on the quality of the grain and therefore the flour, and then going all the way back to the loaf of bread that is consistent. So that is the most important bit – tracing it all the way back.”
Part of the inspiration for looking more closely at regenerative agriculture came from Bertie’s long-standing connection with Ian Wilkinson, co-founder of FarmED and a familiar figure in regenerative farming. The two go back rather further than business. “He has known me since I was about six,” says Bertie. “I think I was dropped off at the wrong child’s party once, and he reminds me of that story.”
Bertie Matthews, managing director of Matthews Cotswold Flour (Image: Lewis Clarke)
As Bertie was beginning to think about the longer-term direction of the family business, the work being demonstrated through FarmED began to look increasingly relevant. “I realised that running a flour mill, trying to make it successful, is all wonderful, and getting growth and buying new machines and working with great customers,” he says. “But actually what he was doing up there was going to have a direct impact on the quality commitment that we have to make in the product that we make, but also the long-term supply-chain security.”
For a business that hopes still to be sourcing British grain decades from now, soil health is therefore more than an environmental talking point. “We want to be buying from these farms all around this area and the rest of the country in 20, 30, 40 years’ time,” says Bertie. “So we needed to take consideration of the positive work of regenerative agriculture on those farms and encourage those farmers and support them into transition, and actually request that they farm in this particular way. It is for our long-term supply-chain security as much as the quality of the product.”
There is no single vague promise sitting behind Matthews Cotswold Flour’s approach. Bertie says traceability is the starting point, followed by measuring what is happening to soil, biodiversity, carbon, water and food security over time. “We need to know where it comes from,” he says. “We need to understand and measure the positive impact that it is having in five key areas – soil, biodiversity, carbon sequestration, so carbon out of the atmosphere into the soil, water and food security. So it is producing enough wheat and a high enough quality wheat.”
Independent scrutiny is also important. Bertie says the farms are audited with the involvement of A Greener World, with information gathered about their crops, yields and farming practices before a physical audit and assessment takes place. “It all needs to be third-party audited as well,” he says. “So it is not us saying it and the farmer saying it, but somebody who is not us is also saying it. Independently audited, measurable, and it is about positive deliverable outcomes.”
Guided tour of Matthews Cotswold Flour (Image: Matthews Cotswold Flour)
Much of the direct relationship with growers comes through the Cotswold Grain Partnership, which links the mill with farming businesses and gives growers the opportunity to produce a wider variety of grains. Instead of relying solely on standard wheat crops, Bertie talks about farmers potentially working with rye, spelt, einkorn, emmer, heritage wheats and different groups of milling wheat. A more varied crop rotation can have agronomic benefits for the farm, he says, while speciality crops can also offer a different route to market.
It is equally about putting farmers and bakers into the same conversation. “The farmer understands the importance of what he is doing to the baker and we can send the bakers over to the farm,” says Bertie. “You have got that communication both ways. So that is what the Cotswold Grain Partnership is all about – collaboration for a reason and for a positive reason for all the people who are going to be fed by the wheat that is growing on the farms.”
The changes Bertie hopes to see become particularly tangible when he starts talking about soil. Rather than treating it simply as the material in which a crop happens to grow, regenerative systems put its condition at the heart of the farm. “What you want is really dark, healthy, spongy soil that is holding more water,” he says. If the ground can retain more water during dry periods, plants have a greater reserve to draw upon, while when heavy rain arrives more can stay in the soil rather than running off and taking valuable topsoil with it.
Over a period of years, Bertie says the same approach should allow farmers to measure changes in soil organic matter, carbon and biodiversity, including insects, plants and birds. He is also interested in whether regenerative systems can reduce some of the dramatic swings in crop yield from one season to another, making the finances of farming easier to forecast and strengthening food security. “These are the impacts we want to see because healthier soil, healthier farm, healthier supply chain, improved food security,” he says. “That is the idea.”
None of that means changing farming systems comes without risk. “This is not a risk-devoid model,” Bertie says. “There are risks.” During the transition, he says a farm could potentially experience a yield reduction of between three and eight per cent, which is why Matthews pays premiums intended to help offset some of the difference.
There can, however, be savings elsewhere. Bertie says farms involved in the approach have reported reductions in inputs of between 33% and 45%, potentially reducing their exposure to the cost of products such as fertiliser. “It is our job as a customer of the farmer, but more importantly as a partner, to understand those risks, to help them mitigate those risks so that we are not asking farms to do something that is economically unviable,” he says. His summary is straightforward: “The most sustainable farm is a financially sustainable farm.”
Guided tour of Matthews Cotswold Flour (Image: Matthews Cotswold Flour)
Once the crop is ready, the journey from regenerative field to loaf becomes more familiar. Matthews discusses with growers what its bakers are likely to need, translating demand for different types of flour into contracts for particular grains. Winter crops may be sown in September or October, cover crops can be incorporated into rotations and sheep may graze fields before the grain itself is harvested; this year, Bertie says, some wheat came off the fields in July rather than the more usual August.
After harvest, the grain is stored, tested and kept separate before being collected and taken to the mill. There it is tested again, cleaned and conditioned with water before being stoneground or roller-milled, sifted into different flours, stored and packed. From there it can travel to around 500 bakeries across the UK.
The fact that grain varies from field to field and harvest to harvest does not mean the baker should have to contend with an unpredictable bag of flour. That, Bertie says, is where the craft of milling comes in. “That is the miller’s job,” he says. “The miller’s job is to ascertain what grains are out there each year and grist, which is like blending different wheats if need be, to be able to create the same quality and consistency that the baker needs.”
Awareness among bakers has changed markedly since the company began putting greater emphasis on regenerative grain. Bertie says relatively few understood the distinction six or seven years ago, but education through farm visits, conversations, videos and information on products has helped. He also welcomes the fact that other businesses are entering the field, arguing that regenerative agriculture can only become significant if it grows beyond individual brands.
The commercial response has been notable. “I think probably 90% of our new business is through regenerative agriculture versus anything else,” he says. “So if that is the marker of growth, then I will take it.” In his view, the meaningful measure of regenerative farming’s progress by 2030 will not be the success of one mill or one label, but the proportion of British food ultimately coming from regenerative systems.
There remains an obvious question for shoppers: price. Matthews pays farmers an incentive for regeneratively grown grain, so Bertie accepts there is currently a difference, although he estimates that when translated into the cost of a supermarket loaf it might amount to around two or three pence. The bigger ambition is to shrink that difference as regenerative production expands.
“My fear is it will go the way of organic, which is it will become a niche thing for the middle classes,” says Bertie. “If this is really going to work, regen farming just needs to be farming, or good farming, and regen food or flour just needs to be flour. It is just the way it needs to be.” He says the current differential of perhaps five to eight per cent needs eventually to disappear if regenerative food is to move firmly into the mainstream.
Matthews Cotswold Flour has set itself the goal of sourcing its grain through regenerative farming by 2030 and Bertie believes it is now at about 30%, or almost a third of the way there. Yet he is wary of rushing simply to hit a number if doing so compromises quality, affordability or credibility. “People have got to believe that it is tangible and it is real and you are not greenwashing it,” he says. “You have got to open yourself up to scrutiny. You have to open up what you are doing and why you are doing it.”
“It is a long game,” he adds. “We are not in a rush to do this even though there is a target. Targets focus the mind, but that is our end goal and I believe we will get there.”
His hopes for the next five, ten or 15 years extend beyond simply producing a greater volume of regenerative flour. Bertie would like more people to visit farms and the mill, to learn where their food comes from and to experiment with speciality and heritage grains. He also wants to continue working closely with independent bakeries, which he regards as a vital source of ideas and practical feedback.
“They are everything for us because they are our new product development team, they are our testing team, they are our sampling team, they are our sounding board,” he says. “Those artisan bakers are the ones that are driving the baking industry forward. So continuing to support them would be key.”
British Regenerative Farming Week gives that conversation a wider platform. Bertie believes farmers, food producers, bakers, manufacturers, retailers and shoppers all have influence over what happens next, particularly as larger retailers and manufacturers gain access to the data and supply chains needed to work with regenerative ingredients. “Regenerative agriculture is happening now and it is developing fast,” he says. “It now has the ability to scale.”
“We have got to see it in breads, cookies, flatbreads, cereals, the whole lot,” he adds. “They have got the power to really turn the dial up.” For farmers themselves, his invitation is equally clear – and particularly relevant in the South West.
“If any farmers are considering implementing regenerative practices or looking to get on the Matthews regen ag scheme, then please do get in touch,” says Bertie. “Whether it is something from now or over the course of the next few years, we are looking for farmers all over the country, particularly in the South West. We are happy to have a conversation and lay out a roadmap for them.”
For shoppers, his advice is simply to start looking more closely: at labels, at where ingredients have come from and at the farmers increasingly sharing what they do online. Matthews Cotswold Flour has further information at https://cotswoldflour.com/, while British Regenerative Farming Week runs from Saturday, September 12, to Saturday, September 19. The campaign is led and sponsored by RISE Re, with further information about the organisation at https://riseregenflour.co.uk/products/.
Share