As this year's drought continues to bites after one of the wettest winters on record, farming organisations say the Government needs to do far more if on-farm water storage is to become a serious part of Britain's food security strategy.
Crops have died in the field, yields have fallen sharply and livestock are already being fed winter rations, raising concerns about feed supplies in the months ahead. Heat stress has also taken its toll on dairy herds, with temperatures exceeding 30°C for 35 days this year.
The Government has responded with a £65 million support package, including £15m specifically for farmers looking to build on-farm reservoirs.
But for many in the industry, the announcement is a welcome start rather than a solution.
During a visit to a family farm in Cornwall on Saturday, Prime Minister Andy Burnham announced the package as "new money coming from Defra budgets".
He said the measures were "hopefully a sign of intent and an indication to the industry that we want a new conversation."
Of the £65m, £50m will go into this year's Sustainable Farming Incentive pot, while £15m will support the construction of on-farm reservoirs.
The package is intended to help farmers get water to thirsty crops, keep livestock fed where grass has failed and continue environmental work during the drought.
Farmers will also be given greater flexibility within environmental schemes. Those managing wildlife habitats who would normally be unable to graze or cut areas until later in the year will, in certain circumstances, be able to use the land when grass is scarce without losing their payments.
Mr Burnham said: "With the parched nature of the fields, it's really important that they can use all of the available land to graze cattle and livestock and sheep."
For farmers considering a reservoir, however, the big question is whether £15m will go far enough.
Gavin Lane, president of the Country Land and Business Association, welcomed the move but warned it was only a first step.
Mr Lane said: "The government has reallocated existing money from the farming budget to help farmers combat drought. This is a welcome and pragmatic move, but little more than a temporary fix.
"The announcement that government will make it easier to build on-farm reservoirs is a positive step, but the £15m made available will fund a fraction of the reservoirs we need. This needs to become a sustained programme, with planning and abstraction lined up in support.
"The vast bulk of the cost of building on-farm reservoirs will still fall on farmers, who are already facing record costs as well as absorbing new tax burdens. Today's announcement is a step forward, but it will not change the reality that farming remains exceptionally difficult in this business environment, and in a country that does not have a plan for climate change adaption."
There is another obstacle facing farmers who want to dig a hole, fill it with water and put it to work: red tape.
Jeremy Moody, secretary and adviser to the Central Association for Agricultural Valuers, says Britain needs to rethink how it manages water before increasingly extreme weather puts even more pressure on farming.
Mr Moody said: “Having taken water for granted for so long, we should now learn from those who have always had much less and use it more carefully while still growing crops and keeping animals.
“We need to identify how to harvest and abstract water best, store it well and then use it most efficiently, taking advantage of when our extreme weathers bring long periods of rain instead.”
The problem, he says, is that building the reservoir is only part of the battle.
Environmental Impact Assessment rules can override permitted development rights, while existing planning restrictions can limit development within 25 metres of trunk or classified roads.
Farmers can also face restrictions on taking minerals excavated during reservoir construction off site, while rules limit the use of waste materials brought onto farmland.
Mr Moody added: “The frustrating interactions with both EIAs and the abstraction rights needed to fill reservoirs require a much more serious approach by government.
“It needs to ease the complexity, delay and cost of processes that depend on Natural England and the Environment Agency as well as planners.”
The cost of construction is another hurdle.
Mr Moody says changes to tax allowances could make a significant difference to farmers facing the considerable expense of creating their own water storage.
Accelerating the Structures and Buildings Allowance could help, he says, while another option would be to widen the Annual Investment Allowance.
“Alternatively, the Annual Investment Allowance could be increased and widened to cover such work.”
For farmers who can afford the investment and secure the necessary permissions, reservoirs could offer much more than an insurance policy against a dry summer. As periods of water scarcity become more frequent, storing water when it is available could become an increasingly important part of farm management.
Mr Moody said: “That may mean protecting stored water from evaporation and moving from rain gun irrigation to more effective technology.”
Reservoirs can also provide an on-farm water supply in the event of wildfire and create opportunities for wildlife.
The principle is simple: capture more of the water when nature provides it, then use it when the fields need it most. Yet turning that principle into reality requires farmers to take on a substantial financial commitment and navigate a planning and abstraction system that industry groups say remains unnecessarily complicated.
The Government's £15m reservoir fund may therefore be a sign that Westminster is beginning to recognise the importance of farm water storage.
The pressure groups' message is that recognition needs to turn into a long-term plan.
Mr Moody added: “With yet more extremes of weather to come, this is reshaping what we do and how we do it.
“Farmers need to futureproof their businesses and food production, and the Government needs to make it easier for them to do so.”
Share