Claims that Natural England has recommended a mass cull of Dartmoor ponies are "simply untrue", the organisation has said as it sought to counter reports circulating in recent weeks.
The government adviser on nature conservation has insisted ponies remain a vital part of Dartmoor's landscape and wildlife recovery efforts, while stressing it has neither proposed nor recommended any cull of the animals.
Natural England said recent media reports had incorrectly suggested it wanted up to 90 per cent of Dartmoor's ponies removed from the moor.
David Slater, Natural England's south west regional director, said: “The notion that Natural England is advocating a cull is simply untrue. Dartmoor's unique habitats are in a poor state and grazing by ponies is vital for their recovery.
“Our role is to advise farmers who wish to enter the publicly funded schemes available for grazing regimes. These government schemes have been designed to restore nature - some areas will require less grazing and some more, dependent on local conditions, but ponies are and should always be part of the mix on Dartmoor.
“We work very closely with partners on Dartmoor to find a way forward that protects livelihoods and the special character of Dartmoor, including its ponies.”
Natural England said Dartmoor's moorland habitats were currently in poor condition, with wildlife and biodiversity continuing to decline.
The organisation said restoring the moorland was important not only for wildlife but also for local communities, citing concerns about flooding and the impacts of climate change.
It said Dartmoor ponies played a significant role in conservation grazing because of the way they feed, helping maintain a balance of habitats and preventing coarse grasses such as Molinia from becoming dominant.
Responding to claims that it had recommended a cull of 90 per cent of ponies on Dartmoor, Natural England said it had no powers to order a cull and had never advised one.
The organisation also rejected suggestions that a cull could begin this autumn, saying reports had confused its role with the annual Dartmoor pony round-up, known as the drift.
Natural England said the drift was a long-established management practice carried out by commoners to check welfare, identify animals and manage numbers through sales or rehousing. Decisions about individual ponies remain with their owners, it added.
The organisation further denied claims that it was attempting to remove ponies from Dartmoor, insisting it wanted them to remain a central part of the moor's grazing system.
Addressing criticism that its approach conflicts with the independent Fursdon Review, Natural England said its position aligned with the review's conclusions that Dartmoor's ecosystems were in decline and required collaborative management to restore nature while supporting farming.
It also disputed claims that it had demanded a 75 per cent reduction in livestock grazing across Dartmoor, describing grazing arrangements as site-specific and agreed locally with farmers and commoners according to habitat conditions.
Natural England acknowledged concerns that including ponies within livestock unit calculations could encourage some land managers to favour cattle or sheep. However, it said the move would ensure ponies were properly recognised within agri-environment payment schemes.
The organisation said decisions about which animals graze on Dartmoor commons remained with landowners and commoners rather than Natural England.
Natural England also said it recognised concerns about the future of the Dartmoor pony breed. Semi-wild Dartmoor Hill Ponies have been included on the Rare Breeds Survival Trust watchlist.
It said it was working with the Department for Environment, Food and Rural Affairs to consider whether financial support currently available for registered Dartmoor ponies could be extended to hill ponies.
Natural England said it remained committed to working with the Dartmoor Land Use Management Group, commoners and landowners to develop a long-term plan that supports both nature recovery and the future of Dartmoor ponies.
The organisation added that discussions with landowners were continuing ahead of the expiry of some existing stewardship agreements, while a wider review by the Dartmoor Land Use Management Group remains ongoing.
Share