Police, farmers and business leaders have painted a stark picture of rising crime, mounting pressures on rural communities and a justice system struggling to keep pace.
A wide-ranging debate at the Devon County Show heard concerns over everything from fly-tipping and livestock attacks to shoplifting, youth offending and organised waste crime, with speakers warning that rural areas are increasingly bearing the cost.
The discussion, chaired by Devon County Show president John Lee OBE DL, brought together Devon and Cornwall Police and Crime Commissioner Alison Hernandez, Devon National Farmers' Union chairman David Chugg, the Bishop of Exeter, the Rt Rev Mike Harrison, and Mole Avon chief executive Mike Haines.
One audience member challenged why authorities appeared unable to tackle persistent fly-tipping hotspots, despite repeated complaints from residents and businesses.
Describing Devon's natural environment as one of its greatest assets, he said large-scale dumping and roadside litter were damaging both the county's appearance and rural enterprises that depend on tourism and the countryside.
The panel of experts at the Devon County Show (Image: Lewis Clarke)
Responding, Alison Hernandez acknowledged longstanding frustrations around enforcement and said agencies had struggled to overcome responsibility disputes between councils and police.
She said: "We largely have a huge problem at the moment with evidence capture."
Alison said councils were facing severe financial pressures, limiting the number of enforcement officers available to investigate incidents, while upcoming local government reorganisation and police reforms risked creating further disruption.
She warned that some cases involved sophisticated criminal operations rather than opportunistic offenders.
"Some of this is actually organised criminals," she said.
"There are people coming in from outside the area and dumping waste. Some of the larger sites we have seen elsewhere in the country involve transport and logistics networks moving waste around. It is a real challenge."
Alison said the National Crime Agency had become involved in tackling major waste crime through a national joint unit, reflecting growing concerns about the scale of the problem.
However, when asked where fly-tipping ranked among policing priorities, she delivered a blunt assessment.
"Quite near the bottom, unfortunately," she said.
(Image: Cambs Police)
Alison argued that violence had become the most significant challenge facing Devon and Cornwall, overtaking crimes many people traditionally associate with policing.
"Violence is our problem in Devon," she said.
"Whether that is in the home or on the street, violence is what we are trying to address at the moment because it is increasing and we do not seem to be able to stop it."
She added that violence against women and girls had been described by the Government as an epidemic, placing additional demands on already stretched resources.
Rural crime was also raised by Devon NFU chairman David Chugg, who spoke about the impact of dog attacks on livestock.
Referring to a recent case in Cornwall, David questioned whether penalties imposed by the courts reflected the financial losses suffered by farmers.
He said one farmer had reportedly lost between £7,000 and £8,000 following an attack, while the offender received a financial penalty of less than £1,000.
"I struggle when a successful court case results in a fine of that amount when the farmer has lost so much money," he said.
Alison agreed there were concerns about the criminal justice system, particularly around delays and court backlogs.
She described the system as "creaky" and warned that increasing pressure on prisons could result in more offenders serving shorter proportions of their sentences before being released.
"We are in a situation where more offenders and more criminals will be in the community and not have served the sentence that we would have thought was justified," she said.
The Bishop of Exeter highlighted concerns about crime and anti-social behaviour in Exeter city centre, pointing to links between offending, addiction, mental health issues and childhood trauma.
Mike Harrison said many people involved in persistent offending had complex backgrounds and vulnerabilities, requiring long-term support from organisations working across the city.
However, he also warned of growing concerns around groups of teenagers gathering in large numbers and engaging in theft and anti-social behaviour.
"We are beginning to see some of that in Exeter as well, which is deeply problematic," he said.
"What is it that enables these young people to have more constructive ways of gathering together in ways which are both upbuilding of society and upbuilding of themselves?"
Alison said there was a need for greater intervention with young offenders while also supporting families.
She argued that policies aimed at avoiding the criminalisation of children had, in some cases, allowed repeated offending to continue unchecked.
"We should be dealing with them more robustly when they are committing crime," she said.
The impact of crime on businesses was also highlighted by Mole Avon chief executive Mike Haines, who described shoplifting as a growing threat across rural towns.
He said retail staff were increasingly finding themselves on the front line and often felt unsupported.
"Shoplifting is becoming a pandemic," he said.
"It is our colleagues at the front of the store who are facing these challenges every day."
Mike warned that theft was adding to rising business costs at a time when retailers were already facing pressure from increasing energy, staffing and operating expenses.
Every item stolen ultimately reduced profitability and limited businesses' ability to invest for future growth, he said.
In response, Alison urged businesses to sign up to UK Partners Against Crime, a national intelligence-sharing initiative designed to help identify prolific offenders and improve police responses.
The system enables retailers to share evidence and track repeat offenders across multiple locations, helping police build stronger cases.
Throughout the debate, speakers returned repeatedly to the same underlying concern: that rural communities increasingly feel they are fighting a growing range of crimes with fewer resources available to tackle them.
Share