Future of trail hunting cut through British political divide

A traditional Boxing Day meet in Tiverton <i>(Image: Lewis Clarke)</i>
A traditional Boxing Day meet in Tiverton (Image: Lewis Clarke)
This article is brought to you by our exclusive subscriber partnership with our sister title USA Today, and has been written by our American colleagues. It does not necessarily reflect the view of The Herald.

The cry of hounds across Exmoor has echoed through valleys and farmland for centuries. To some, it is the soundtrack of rural Britain - a tradition stitched into the identity of communities from Cornwall to Somerset. To others, it is the lingering shadow of a blood sport the country outlawed more than 20 years ago.

Now, a fresh political battle is unfolding across the countryside.

The Government’s proposed ban on trail hunting has reignited one of Britain’s most emotionally charged rural arguments, dividing farmers, hunt supporters, wildlife campaigners and politicians once again. Interviews broadcast on BBC Politics South West this weekend revealed just how raw the debate remains, with accusations of cruelty colliding against fears of cultural erasure and the collapse of rural traditions.

A foxA fox (Image: Anne Burgess / Geograph)

At the heart of the argument is trail hunting - the practice introduced after the Hunting Act 2004 banned fox hunting with dogs. Instead of pursuing a live fox, hounds follow a scent trail laid artificially across countryside land.

But ministers argue the system leaves too much room for abuse.

Launching a consultation on proposals to outlaw trail hunting, the Government said the practice makes it difficult to guarantee wild animals are not endangered when hounds pick up the scent of real foxes instead. Ministers have also cited concerns from police leaders that some hunts may use trail hunting as cover for illegal fox hunting.

The consultation closes on Thursday, June 18. For those whose lives revolve around hunts, the prospect has landed like a personal blow.

On his farm in Cornwall, Paul Hancock walks among 70 hounds he says he knows individually. Mr Hancock, joint master of the Four Burrow Hunt, spoke with visible emotion about what a ban could mean for him and others involved in rural hunts.

“Distraught, really,” he said.

“Farming and hunting was my life. I was brought up on a farm, working with all the people in the countryside, and it has been a privilege.

“But I am so annoyed with this government. There are so many things in this country that ought to be sorted out, rather than what we do.”

A foxhoundA foxhound (Image: Walter Baxter / Geograph)

For Paul, hunting is not simply recreation. It is infrastructure - social, agricultural and generational. Hunts in the South West often support kennels, horse yards, farriers, feed suppliers and rural pubs, while providing a social calendar around point-to-points and countryside gatherings.

Yet opponents argue that tradition cannot excuse suffering.

Drone footage filmed in Somerset and discussed during the BBC programme appeared to show hounds chasing a fox. Hunt saboteur Chris Tuite, from Wiltshire Hunt Saboteurs, claimed such incidents are far from isolated.

“Every day that we go out and follow with the drone, we see evidence of hunting,” he said.

“Looking for foxes, actually chasing foxes. And then on these occasions when we actually witness the kill…”

Wildlife campaigners argue the footage strengthens the case that trail hunting has become impossible to police effectively.

Roger Swaine, a wildlife guardian, said hunts could instead move towards drag hunting — where dogs follow a completely artificial scent rather than one linked to foxes.

“There are drag hunts around the country right now that are perfectly legal, and we do not have an issue with that,” he said.

“It is a safer alternative, relatively cruelty-free, while still having the social aspects of traditional hunting.”

But supporters of trail hunting insist the reality is far more complicated than politicians in Westminster understand.

Retraining hounds bred for generations to follow animal scent trails would not happen overnight, they argue. Hancock said there were serious concerns over what would happen to hunt dogs if trail hunting disappeared entirely.

“If the government wants to do this, that must be their responsibility,” he said.

“What happens to the 70 hounds here on my right?”

That question - what exactly survives if trail hunting vanishes - cuts to the emotional centre of the debate.

For Baroness Mallalieu, the Labour peer and Countryside Alliance president who lives on Exmoor, the issue is not whether illegal hunting should be punished, but whether existing laws already cover it.

“If a fox is chased deliberately, and if a fox is killed that way, then there is a criminal offence being committed,” she said.

“There have indeed been prosecutions of hunts for doing just that and convictions. It is wrong to break the law.”

Ms Mallalieu argued a blanket ban risked criminalising people who were already operating within existing legislation.

“We spent, I think, 700 hours of parliamentary time getting the Hunting Bill through,” she said.

“What is now proposed is that the people who were told to take up drag hunting instead, who perfectly legally have done so, are going to be criminalised as well.”

The veteran peer also suggested there were divisions even among anti-hunting campaigners, with some objecting not simply to fox deaths, but to the broader spectacle of mounted hunts altogether.

Government ministers, however, insist they are not seeking to eradicate all hunting-related activity. The consultation document specifically references support for drag hunting and clean boot hunting - practices using non-animal scents.

Torbay’s former Conservative MP Kevin Foster said he understood why ministers were examining the issue.

“Where trail has become confused, and where it can sometimes be used as a smokescreen, is the idea of using fox urine and then hounds going off on a different scent,” he said.

“I suspect they will make very clear what this specific offence is.”

But Mr Foster also questioned whether the issue should dominate political attention at a time of wider national pressures.

“I would much rather the government was as enthusiastic about delivering its pledge on reducing energy bills as it is about taking on trail hunting,” he said.

For Liberal Democrat MP Rachel Gilmour, whose Tiverton and Honiton constituency includes parts of Exmoor, the debate has become deeply personal for many rural residents.

“I am rampantly opposed to illegal hunting,” she said.

“The idea of chasing a quarry animal with hounds and then ripping it limb from limb is something that I find absolutely abhorrent.

“But that is not what we are talking about here.”

Instead, Ms Gilmour described trail hunting as part of the social fabric of countryside life, particularly in isolated rural communities.

“I was at a point-to-point on top of Exmoor a couple of weeks ago,” she said.

“It was a wonderful, glorious day. Probably 2,000 people there - three or four generations in each family.”

Rachel Gilmour MP at the trail hunting demoRachel Gilmour MP at the trail hunting demo (Image: Rachel Gilmour MP)

She also rejected suggestions that hunts are simply playgrounds for wealthy landowners in red coats.

“Most of the people on Exmoor in my constituency who enjoy following the hunt are living on the minimum wage,” she said.

“It is not about class envy. It is about letting people in rural areas follow the passions and the practices that they have done for generations and generations.”

Yet for critics, the central issue remains difficult to escape.

If hounds are trained to pursue fox scent - even artificially laid scent - can there ever truly be certainty that live foxes will not be chased?

Supporters say accidental incidents are rare. Opponents say the risk is inherent.

More than 20 years after Parliament outlawed fox hunting, Britain still appears unable to settle the question of what should replace it — or whether the culture surrounding hunts can ever be separated from the animal they once pursued.

Across the moors and hedgerows of the South West, the argument is no longer simply about foxes. It is about identity, class, law, cruelty, community and the future of the countryside itself.

And as ministers weigh the responses to their consultation, both sides remain convinced they are fighting for the soul of rural Britain.

Get involved
with the news

Send your news & photos