Key Risks

Diversification crucial after BPS cut as experts urge careful planning

Philip Whitcomb, a private client lawyer specialising in agricultural work at Clarke Willmott LLP, says a structured and well-advised approach is essential before committing to any new venture <i>(Image: Empica)</i>
Philip Whitcomb, a private client lawyer specialising in agricultural work at Clarke Willmott LLP, says a structured and well-advised approach is essential before committing to any new venture (Image: Empica)
This article is brought to you by our exclusive subscriber partnership with our sister title USA Today, and has been written by our American colleagues. It does not necessarily reflect the view of The Herald.

With the phased withdrawal of the Basic Payment Scheme (BPS), income from diversified enterprises is rapidly shifting from being a useful addition to a core pillar of many farming businesses.

Rural and private client specialists are warning that while diversification offers opportunity, it also brings complexity - and getting it wrong could have lasting financial and legal consequences.

Philip Whitcomb, a private client lawyer specialising in agricultural work at Clarke Willmott LLP, says a structured and well-advised approach is essential before committing to any new venture.

“For many farming businesses, diversification is no longer optional - it is fundamental to replacing lost BPS income,” he explains.

“But it has far-reaching implications. It can affect everything from day-to-day cashflow through to succession planning, taxation, and overall business resilience.”

He stresses that early engagement with professional advisers is key, particularly as diversified enterprises often sit outside the traditional farming model.

Whitcomb advises farmers to think holistically and work through a clear framework before proceeding.

The starting point, he says, is identifying the right asset and ensuring the proposed diversification aligns with the long-term vision for the business. Whether that is converting redundant buildings, developing tourism, or introducing a new commercial enterprise, the decision must fit within the wider strategy of the farm.

Planning considerations are another early hurdle. Farmers need to establish whether permission is required and understand any restrictions that could affect the project’s feasibility or timeline.

Equally important is a thorough financial appraisal. Diversification must stand on its own two feet commercially, with realistic projections around income, costs and return on investment.

But beyond the numbers, integration with the existing farming operation is critical. A new enterprise should complement the core business — not create conflict in terms of labour, infrastructure or management time.

Funding is another key consideration. While grants and support schemes may be available, many projects will require private finance or borrowing, making it essential to understand the risk profile from the outset.

Whitcomb also highlights the often-overlooked issue of business rates. A change in land or building use can trigger revaluation, which may have a significant impact on overall profitability.

Deciding who will actually run the diversified enterprise is another fundamental step. In some cases, it may suit a family member; in others, bringing in external expertise or forming a partnership may be more appropriate.

Crucially, any diversification must align with succession planning.

“This is where we often see unintended consequences,” Whitcomb notes.

“A well-meaning diversification project can complicate inheritance structures if it is not carefully thought through.”

Insurance is another area that requires attention. Existing farm policies may not cover new commercial activities, leaving businesses exposed if cover is not updated.

Finally, farmers are urged to consider personal and business risk more broadly - including the potential impact of death, divorce or financial distress - and ensure the right legal structures are in place to protect assets.

“Diversification can absolutely strengthen a farming business,” Whitcomb adds.

“But it needs to be approached with a full understanding of the legal, financial and practical implications. Taking advice early and planning properly can make the difference between success and costly mistakes.”

As the agricultural support landscape continues to evolve, advisers say those who take a proactive, strategic approach to diversification will be best placed to secure long-term sustainability.

Get involved
with the news

Send your news & photos