COMMENT: We need more action to reduce the future impact of flooding

CLA SW Director, Ann Maidment <i>(Image: CLA)</i>
CLA SW Director, Ann Maidment (Image: CLA)
This article is brought to you by our exclusive subscriber partnership with our sister title USA Today, and has been written by our American colleagues. It does not necessarily reflect the view of The Herald.

 Ann Maidment, director for CLA South West writes:

Weeks of relentless rain across south west of England have caused widespread flooding and waterlogging, leaving crops damaged, operations severely disrupted and an uncertain future for farmers and landowners in the months ahead.

Cornwall experienced its wettest January on record. Many areas of the south west have experienced rain every day so far this year, with more to come. Somerset in particular has been subject to widespread flooding, and a major incident alert remains in place across the county. Many are already drawing comparisons to the 2012 Somerset floods, which submerged more than 14,000 hectares of agricultural land and caused more than £10m in estimated damages.

Climate change is often linked to extreme rainfall like this. While it is likely to have played some role, it is tricky to know what its exact contribution has been. Climate change can therefore be a convenient thing to blame as it ignores the importance of river channel maintenance and wider land management in shaping flooding’s severity, which are strongly influenced by government policy and funding.

The long-term lack of river maintenance

In England, watercourses are split into ‘main rivers’ and ‘ordinary watercourses’. Main rivers are those more likely to cause damage if they flood and their maintenance is controlled by the Environment Agency (EA). Ordinary watercourses have oversight from the Internal Drainage Board (IDB) or council (in the form of the Lead Local Flood Authority).

Coordinated maintenance work – like routine vegetation management and removing sediment to maintain river conveyance capacity – sits with the EA not the IDB on main rivers, and riparian owners and other parties must obtain permission from the EA to undertake works. However, the EA only has a ‘permissive’ role in maintenance. It does not have an obligation to maintain rivers so it can largely pick and choose what it does.

Across the country, the EA has reduced the amount of maintenance it undertakes on main rivers.

The real sting in the tail for land managers, however, is that the EA can decide to entirely withdraw its own maintenance responsibilities without downgrading the river’s classification to ‘ordinary watercourse’ - a change which would allow others to step in. This is what happened in Somerset last year, and reflects a pattern seen across England over several decades.

In August 2025, landowners across Somerset were informed that the EA had decided to withdraw maintenance on several main rivers, without prior consultation. The EA has now begun a process of consultation after local IDBs and other rural groups raised serious concerns about the risks from the policy. Whilst this is a welcome step, the fundamental problem of insufficient government funding for maintenance remains unchanged.

The government needs to spend more on maintenance as a proportion of the total floods budget. This is good business sense as maintenance delivers £11 in benefits for every £1 spent and is 2.3 times as cost effective as building new defences at preventing homes from flooding. The CLA emphasised this to HM Treasury in the Spending Review last June. The government has now increased the total floods budget by 5%, has changed the allocation policy to make it easier to fund a category of maintenance, and has made it somewhat easier for the EA to move money between capital and maintenance budgets.

These are partial steps forward, but we will continue to argue for more focus on maintenance. For instance, at the most recent Floods Resilience Taskforce, which Minister Hardy chairs, we pushed strongly for this alongside the Association of Drainage Authorities (ADA) and the NFU.

The government needs to facilitate local groups and riparian owners who want to undertake more maintenance work themselves. This will involve declassifying more main rivers so that riparian owners do not need to seek Flood Risk Activity Permits from the EA before beginning more extensive maintenance.

Another route to local maintenance is to allow new IDBs to form, and existing IDBs to expand their boundaries. This requires change to the Land Drainage Act, which limits IDB scope to their 1991 extent. The previous government drafted legislation to open the door to these changes but the current government has not carried the legislation through.

Upstream solutions

Improving soil health across catchment is essential to reduce the frequency of flooding because soils store millions of litres of water per hectare. If they cannot absorb as much rainfall due to compaction or crusting, then rapid surface runoff occurs, with water reaching rivers all at once across the catchment. Poor soil management causes soil erosion, which chokes rivers with sediment and reduces their conveyance capacity. We are working to challenge attitudes in policy to dredging – highlighting that many of our lowland rivers are heavily modified and do not have the discharge rates to flush sediment out – but it remains true that much of this sediment shouldn’t be in rivers in the first place.

The UK Government has a role here to design support for more regenerative ways of managing soil health, as a public good. The CLA is advocating for a Sustainable Farming Incentive that all farms can access, to provide transitional support to better soil management. But, there is also a role for industry to improve soil health as far as possible within current farm economics.

After a long period of piloting, the government is ready to mainstream natural flood management (NFM) techniques, and fund them from the main floods budget. The new floods funding policy commits £300m to NFM over the next ten years. Defra will also aim to align NFM with Environmental Land Management (ELM) schemes that fund NFM maintenance, something we highlighted was at risk of forgetting in the consultation on the funding policy.

After sustained advocacy from a broad church of organisations, including the CLA, the government looks set to make Sustainable Drainage Schemes mandatory for new developments across England – building on Wales’s leadership and that of many local authorities. This should reduce the amount of runoff that enters rivers.

Catchments across the country can become far more resilient to flooding, even as climate change makes our weather increasingly unpredictable. Achieving this will require landowners, government, the Environment Agency, Internal Drainage Boards and other parties to work together better.

We are not short of practical solutions, what is now needed is for the government to recognise the vital importance of regular river and watercourse maintenance, provide adequate funding and empower local groups to take action where appropriate to do so.”

 

Get involved
with the news

Send your news & photos