The UK egg sector was absent from a Westminster roundtable this week examining the future of hatch and dispatch despite campaigners and MPs pressing ahead with discussions on a potential pathway to reform.
The meeting, convened in parliament and attended by cross-party MPs and welfare groups, had invited the British Egg Industry Council (BEIC) to take part.
BEIC had initially accepted but withdrew earlier this week, stating that the format presumed consensus that ending chick culling was immediately achievable.
The roundtable went ahead and, organisers said, without representation from major breeding interests. It focused on whether the UK should follow several European countries in setting a timetable to phase out the culling of an estimated 45 million male chicks annually.
Richard McIlwain, chief executive of the Vegetarian Society, described the withdrawal as 'deeply disappointing', while acknowledging the commercial pressures facing producers.
“We know that food production is a difficult, low-margin business, and we have been keen throughout to ensure that any transition to a more ethical system is just and takes the pressures that egg producers face into account,” he said.
He added that in other countries, agreements to end chick culling have been accompanied by multi-year transition periods to allow assessment and installation of in-ovo sexing technology. “But getting an agreement and timeline in place is paramount. Other countries are moving ahead rapidly and the UK is being left behind.”
Campaigners argue that in-ovo sexing systems, which determine the sex of chicks before hatching, are already operating commercially in parts of Europe. Representatives from Norway told MPs that industry concentration in the UK could, in theory, deliver economies of scale if investment were coordinated.
Irene Campbell MP for Labour South Ayrshire, who has been leading the campaign in parliament, said ministers must now clarify their position.
“I’ve been involved in this campaign for a year now, and while we have seen some progress in the government’s recognition of this issue, we need a commitment to action,” she said.
She noted that Defra has previously indicated it intends to wait until 'Day 0' technology is available - referring to genetic solutions that would produce only female chicks. Ms Campbell questioned that approach, pointing instead to existing in-ovo systems.
“Fortunately, what we have works,” she said, describing a recent visit to a Dutch hatchery using MRI and AI to determine sex in the egg before the embryo can feel pain. “By working with the supporters of this campaign we can jointly create a plan to end this cruel and outdated practice.”
Participants at the roundtable, which included MPs from Labour and the Liberal Democrats, veterinary and academic representatives, and Norwegian welfare groups, discussed the importance of a 'fair and just' transition.
According to organisers, topics included funding mechanisms to protect producers and consumers, potential research into alternative uses for male chicks currently destined for raptor feed, and the need for a clear timeline to avoid stranded investment in hatchery equipment.
Norwegian delegates said their roadmap to ending chick culling was supported by government subsidy to offset capital costs, alongside retailer and industry buy-in.
For UK producers, the question remains not simply one of welfare but of cost, competitiveness and technological certainty. With Defra yet to set out a firm timetable, campaigners are now seeking further meetings with ministers to test whether political momentum will translate into policy.
Share