Plans to create a farm shop and cafe at a Malmesbury farm have been rejected by a planning inspector.
Steve Baker of Home Farm, Burton Hill, Corston applied for planning permission to convert an agricultural building into a shop and cafe and to create a car park for the facility in November 2024.
A Wiltshire Council planning officer rejected the proposal to convert the modern steel-framed building, which sits in a yard just off the Malmesbury to Chippenham road, in January 2025.
Mr Baker than appealed to the Planning Inspectorate.
The council had previously denied permission for agricultural buildings on the same site to be converted into housing.
The council said the farm shop application would “constitute development in the countryside for which there is no justification,” and “would introduce parking in a manner alien to the rural landscape and would therefore harm landscape quality and fail to respect the local character.”
It also said that “on-site parking would be necessary in order to ensure highways safety.”
Writing on behalf of the applicant, planning and development practice Willis & Co argued that the site is behind hedges and a wall and “largely hidden from view.”
They added: “The use of the existing yard for the parking of vehicles is not harmful to the character and appearance of the landscape and the planting of a new hedge and trees along the southern boundary, along with the demolition of the smaller barn on the south side of the site – for which prior approval has already been obtained – will not just mitigate any harm, but will positively enhance the character and appearance of the area.”
They concluded: “The benefits far outweigh the limited harm identified by the council, and even that limited harm will be overcome by the proposed landscaping.”
However, the planning inspector found that “the proposal would result in unacceptable highways and transport impacts,” and “moderate harm to the character and appearance of the area.”
He dismissed the appeal and also refused Mr Baker’s claim against the council for costs.
Share