Vertical farming’s hidden carbon footprint revealed

Big water savings, but is the carbon cost too high?
Big water savings, but is the carbon cost too high?
This article is brought to you by our exclusive subscriber partnership with our sister title USA Today, and has been written by our American colleagues. It does not necessarily reflect the view of The Herald.

Vertical farming may promise bumper yields and major water savings, but a new University of Surrey study warns the technology still produces higher carbon emissions than traditional lettuce growing.

Published in Food and Energy Security, the research is the first to fully account for soil emissions from field-grown crops while comparing them with a commercial UK vertical farm. Using a cradle-to-store assessment, the team analysed two British lettuce farms – one on mineral soil and one on peat – plus a Spanish supplier, then set those against a vertical system.

The results show striking advantages in yield and water use: vertical farms produced around 97 kg of lettuce per square metre, over 20 times the 3.3 kg/m² achieved in fields, and used just 0.9 m³ of water per kg compared with up to 7.3 m³/kg in Spain. But the carbon numbers tell a different story. Even when powered by renewable electricity, vertically grown lettuce emitted 0.93 kg of greenhouse gases per kg, compared to 0.57 kg/kg from UK field farms.

Lead author Michael Gargaro said vertical systems could 'transform food security in the UK” as drought and climate change increasingly threaten traditional agriculture'.

"But right now, vertical farming comes with a higher carbon cost,” he warned. Improving energy efficiency and integrating renewables, along with switching from jute fibre plugs to alternatives like coconut coir, could slash impacts – coir alone could cut land footprint by more than 95 %.

Co-author Dr Zoe M Harris noted that with 95 % of winter lettuce imported from Spain, vertical technology could eventually secure a home-grown supply while freeing land for ecosystem restoration.

“To compete with field farming, vertical farms must reduce energy use and rethink their growing materials,” she said.

The authors conclude that vertical farming isn’t yet the lowest-carbon option, but with targeted improvements, it could become a critical part of the UK’s long-term food security strategy.

Get involved
with the news

Send your news & photos