A government-commissioned review into the 'employer pays' recruitment model has sparked widespread concern across the UK horticulture industry, with the National Farmers’ Union (NFU) warning that the findings could push many growers to the brink of collapse.
The independent review, commissioned by Defra and the industry-led Seasonal Worker Taskforce, examined the implications of forcing growers to shoulder the full cost of recruiting seasonal workers. It concluded that such a move could severely undermine the financial viability of businesses already struggling with razor-thin profit margins – as low as 2% in many cases.
The employer pays principle requires employers to absorb all recruitment-related expenses, aiming to combat global issues where migrant workers are often burdened with high agency or broker fees to secure employment. While the intention is to protect vulnerable workers, the review acknowledges that the proposed changes could have significant unintended consequences for UK producers.
Latest News
Iceland faces backlash after scrapping cage-free egg commitment
NFU urges urgent food education reform to protect future food security
Lidl pledges 100% British beef as supermarkets face backlash over imports
“While some of these costs might be recoverable, many businesses would still face serious financial losses,” the report warns. “In extreme cases, this could result in closures, job losses, and a fall in domestic food production.”
Reacting to the findings, Martin Emmett, chair of the NFU Horticulture and Potatoes Board, said the review confirms what many in the sector have long feared. “Seasonal workers play a vital role in getting the nation’s favourite fresh produce onto supermarket shelves,” said Mr Emmett. “Without them, the sector simply wouldn’t function.”
“Most businesses already operate on tight margins, and asking them to shoulder all recruitment costs would push some over the edge. That directly contradicts the government’s Food Strategy, which aims to make healthy food more accessible to all.”
Mr Emmett also criticised the review for not adequately addressing the scale or prevalence of worker debt. “This is a critical issue and needs further exploration. We must find the right balance—protecting workers while safeguarding the future of UK horticulture and food security.”
He added that growers care deeply about worker welfare and are actively collaborating across the supply chain to improve working conditions for seasonal staff.
The Seasonal Worker Taskforce, which includes scheme operators, growers, trade bodies, distributors and retailers, was set up to ensure ethical recruitment and uphold worker rights in the UK’s seasonal labour system. Mr Emmett stressed the NFU’s continued commitment to working with the taskforce to consider the review's findings and agree next steps.
“This review is part of our ongoing efforts to improve the system,” he said. “But any changes must not come at the cost of British farming or our food supply.”
Share