Couple sentenced after cattle mistreated in Shrewton

Michael and Julie Babey were sentenced at Salisbury Magistrates' Court on Thursday <i>(Image: Wiltshire Council)</i>
Michael and Julie Babey were sentenced at Salisbury Magistrates' Court on Thursday (Image: Wiltshire Council)
This article is brought to you by our exclusive subscriber partnership with our sister title USA Today, and has been written by our American colleagues. It does not necessarily reflect the view of The Herald.

A MAN who caused suffering to cattle by keeping them in poor conditions, despite being banned from caring for them, has avoided jail.

Michael John Babey, 69, of Whatcombe Brow in Orcheston, was found guilty of animal welfare offences and breaching a disqualification order in March.

He avoided prison at Salisbury Magistrates’ Court on Thursday (April 22) and had his 20-week jail sentence suspended for two years.

His wife Julie Teresa Babey, 52, pleaded guilty in May 2024 to animal welfare offences and aiding and abetting her husband in breaching his disqualification order.

She was fined and made subject to a 12-month community order.

Both sets of charges related to cattle kept on land at Tanners Lane in Shrewton.

In 2019, Mr Babey was banned from keeping cattle and cows for five years.

After he was disqualified, his wife became the owner of the cattle – but animal health officers found that Mr Babey continued to care for them.

The court was told this was a “clumsy attempt to get around the order."

In November 2023, an animal health officer visited with a vet from the Animal & Plant Health Agency (APHA) and found 24 cattle on the half-acre site.

Records showed the cattle had an overall mortality rate of 31 per cent. The mortality rate across England in 2023 was just over five per cent.

Eleven cattle were kept in one pen in heavily soiled conditions, and their feeding area was covered in deep slurry and mud.

The pen was found to be non-compliant with legal requirements because there was insufficient space for all the cattle to lie down at once.

A follow-up visit later that month found that conditions had not sufficiently improved.

In January 2024, the farm was visited again by officers and the APHA vet, where 23 cattle were found to have no access to water.

One cow was seen licking an empty water container for five minutes. 

There was no running water at the site, and the animals were reliant on water being brought to the site in a container.

Wiltshire Council successfully prosecuted the couple.

On Thursday, the prosecution told the court that, when interviewed, Mr Babey claimed that cows could go for three days without water, and Mrs Babey confirmed she owned the cattle but did not know how many animals there were.

Mr Babey had two previous convictions for animal welfare convictions: the one from 2019, and another relating to equine animals from 2010 that involved the same patch of “unsuitable” land.

The court was told that Mrs Babey was “of previous good character”, it was unclear if she was willing to become the named owner or not, and she would “readily recognise that she knows nothing about farming” and was not involved in the cows' day-to-day care.

She pleaded guilty at the earliest opportunity.

Sentencing Mr Babey, magistrate Sarah Neish told him the animals had suffered and said: “You were found guilty at trial of a number of offences.

“This is the third time you have been before the court. There have been previous convictions of poor welfare of animals.

“You have shown over a period an inability to look after animals properly.”

The couple were sentenced in SalisburyThe couple were sentenced in Salisbury Both have been banned from keeping all animals except dogs, cats and cockatiels, which they currently own with no evidence of mistreatment, for 10 years.

They can apply to vary that disqualification in five years.

Mr Babey was told to pay £5,000 in costs, plus a £154 surcharge to fund victim services.

Mrs Babey was fined £100 and ordered to pay £200 in costs and a £114 surcharge.

Parvis Khansari, corporate director for place at Wiltshire Council, said: “We have a dedicated team of animal health officers at Wiltshire Council who will act quickly to ensure that Wiltshire farmers and livestock owners take good care of their animals.

“Mr and Mrs Babey show little regard for the law and for the welfare of their cattle.

“I hope that the sentencing today sends a strong message that breaking animal welfare law and mistreatment of animals will not be tolerated in Wiltshire.

“If anyone has concerns related to the health and welfare of livestock, they can contact the animal health team on 0300 456 0100.”

Get involved
with the news

Send your news & photos