Peer relies on ‘rustic expression’ to warn over SFI scheme closure

Combine harvesting, stock image. <i>(Image: Getty Images/iStockphoto)</i>
Combine harvesting, stock image. (Image: Getty Images/iStockphoto)
This article is brought to you by our exclusive subscriber partnership with our sister title USA Today, and has been written by our American colleagues. It does not necessarily reflect the view of The Herald.

Ministers have been warned over “piddling down people’s backs and telling them that it’s raining” after the abrupt closure of a flagship, nature-friendly, farming payments scheme.

Independent crossbencher Lord Cromwell cited the “rustic expression” in Parliament as he tackled the Government over the “latest disaster” to hit the industry, coming in the wake of inheritance tax changes.

The Environment Department (Defra) announced late last Tuesday that the sustainable farming incentive (SFI), which pays farmers in England for “public goods” such as insecticide-free farming, wildflower strips and managing ponds and hedgerows, was fully allocated for this year.

As a result, the scheme was shut to new applications with immediate effect.

This was despite a commitment on the official Government website to give six weeks’ notice if it was withdrawn.

Farming minister Daniel Zeichner further fuelled controversy after he told MPs the oversubscription of the scheme and all the money being used up was a “cause for celebration”, with so many now farming in an environmentally sensitive way.

Speaking in the Lords following a repeat of the ministerial statement on the closure of the initiative, Lord Cromwell said the minister had “waited until the money ran out and slammed the door – overnight – on more than half of English agricultural holdings”.

The director of a family farming and property company in Leicestershire pointed out this was “in breach of the six-week notice period that was cynically, overnight, airbrushed off the Defra website”.

Lord Cromwell added: “His only reason for this was that there might otherwise have been a rush of applications.

“His only advice to farmers was to apply immediately for any new SFI that is opened, which is surely itself a recipe for a precipitous rush.

“It also ignores that inquiries to Defra by farmers seeking to get their applications right take months to get a reply.

“It took me three years to get answers, and those were still incomplete when the scheme was shut in the face of my family farm.”


Recommended reading:


The peer went on: “Finally, the minister then tells hard-pressed rural communities that his department running out of money should be a cause for celebration.

“I cannot help but recall the rustic expression, ‘don’t piddle down my back and tell me that it’s raining’.

“Can the minister tell the House what lessons have been learned from this latest disaster for so many family farms?”

Responding, environment minister Baroness Hayman of Ullock said it was not the first time that SFI had been paused.

She told peers: “The way the scheme operates is that it opens for applications and, when the funding is used up, it is then paused until we look at the next round of SFI funding. It is difficult to judge when that is likely to come to an end.

“We are aware that the SFI scheme needs reforming, which is what we are now looking at doing.

“We need to get it right and we need it to work better for farmers and for the environment.”

The minister added:” I am very aware that the sudden closure, when farmers were expecting more notice, has not been easy and that, for many people who were intending to put in applications … has caused difficulties.

“I have friends who are in that boat, so I am very aware that difficulties were caused.

“I will take the concerns of the House back to the farming minister and explain that the unexpected pause and its impacts are felt very strongly by this House. I am happy to commit to do that, because it is important.”

Get involved
with the news

Send your news & photos