Column

NFU column from George Horsford, Dorset, on BPS and SFI

George Hosford. <i>(Image: NFU/Getty Images)</i>
George Hosford. (Image: NFU/Getty Images)
This article is brought to you by our exclusive subscriber partnership with our sister title USA Today, and has been written by our American colleagues. It does not necessarily reflect the view of The Herald.

Following the announcement of the drastic decapitation of the Basic payment scheme (BPS) after last autumn’s budget, which created a rumble of upset and worry throughout English farming, renowned Cumbrian shepherd and author James Rebanks said he believed that the progressive greener dream for UK farming had died. I have tried hard not to agree with him, but am now very depressed by having to admit that I do.

On March 11, Defra announced the sudden closure of the SFI extended offer (2024). To do this to what was originally described as a rolling application scheme, ie you can apply at any time in the year, within five months of the sudden decapitation of the basic payment scheme, is heart-stoppingly shocking, and desperately sad. The likely consequences are truly scary.

We were fooled into believing that SFI would expand as BPS declined, at the same time encouraging us to produce food in more sustainable ways. Many farmers have committed a great deal of energy to new ways of farming, using countryside stewardship (CS) and SFI as a backstop while they explore new ways of growing food which do more benefit to the environment. This is the most staggering betrayal of farmers who are bold enough to try to do the right thing.

It is incredibly difficult to wean yourself off one production system for another when there is such huge pressure on farmers to feed a growing population and also deliver more environmental gains, and without the support of schemes like the SFI it will struggle to happen.

In our own case, we have an SFI 24 scheme entered up on the RPA site, which has been held up while the RPA made adjustments to many of our fields due to rotational offers from the SFI 23 scheme which conflict with the SFI 24 scheme. For example, the no insecticide option (IPM4) cannot run alongside the low input cereal option (AHW10) in the newest iteration of the scheme, on the same piece of land.

READ MORE: Halting new farm SFI applications 'another shattering blow'

This in itself shows, arguably, the whole thing is far too complicated. This week we were doing the final checks on an already complicated plan to ensure it was achievable before pressing the button. Then Defra suddenly pulled the plug, with no warning, or deadline or reasonable explanation. We will now actually be worse off than we were last year.

You need trust to get these things to work, and they have just completely shattered that trust. If you have similar stories to share, please contact the NFU or your MP.

George Hosford
Member of NFU Dorset

Get involved
with the news

Send your news & photos